Saturday, August 28, 2010

Creamy Peanut Butter Pie

A creamy pie made of peanut butter, cream cheese, cream and brown sugar, prepared in a chocolate cookie crust and garnished with chocolate syrup and chopped peanuts.

Creamy Peanut Butter Pie

It'd be a rare southern cook who didn't have some form of peanut butter pie in his or her dessert repertoire and there are several popular varieties, including a favorite of mine that is what I consider an old fashioned peanut butter pie. Made in layers, beginning with a layer of peanut butter crumble, then topped with a layer of homemade custard mixed with peanut butter and topped with more crumble and often meringue. Now that's old school, scratch cookin' and boy is it delicious! There's also the more popular version that combines peanut butter with often large amounts of non-dairy topping. Quick, easy and also very good.

I've had a few requests lately though for a peanut butter pie that is not so heavy on the whipped topping and more cheesecake-like, and I think that this one achieves that. While it does use some heavy cream, it is only 1/2 a cup, a mere drop in comparison to some of the cream cheese based recipes that call for as much as eight times that!  I used nut mix leftover from my banana splits to top my pie, so while peanuts would be most appropriate, use whatever you have on hand.  Also, where many recipes use powdered sugar, making them sometimes a bit too sweet, we've used brown sugar here instead, which seems to soften that sweetness a bit.  Don't worry, even though this pie is also quick and easy, it is still plenty rich and sweet.

Use a commercial pre-made chocolate pie crust if you like. I used the chocolate sables that I made the other day, which were very rich and didn't need much in the way of additional moisture from the melted butter to bind them. If you are making a homemade cookie crust using plain chocolate wafer cookies, you may need more towards the 4 tablespoons of melted butter.

Here's how to make it.

Recipe: Creamy Peanut Butter Pie

©From the Kitchen of Deep South Dish
Prep time: 10 min |Cook time: 15 min | Yield: About 8 servings


For the Crust:
  • 1-1/2 cups of crushed chocolate cookie crumbs
  • 2 to 4 tablespoons of melted butter, more or less, or just enough to moisten the crumbs
For the Filling:
  • 1/2 cup of heavy whipping cream
  • 1 overflowing teaspoon of pure vanilla extract
  • 1/2 cup of packed light brown sugar
  • 3/4 cup of creamy peanut butter
  • 1 (8 ounce) block of cream cheese, softened to room temperature
  • 1/4 cup of finely chopped peanuts, for garnish
  • Chocolate syrup, for garnish

If making a homemade chocolate cookie crust, preheat oven to 350 degrees F. In a small bowl, combine the cookie crumbs with some of the melted butter until the crumbs begin to bind. You may or may not need all of the butter, depending on the type of cookie you are using. Turn the crumbs out into a 9-inch pie plate and press into the bottom and sides of the pie plate to form a pie crust. Bake at 350 degrees F for 10 to 15 minutes. Let cool completely on a wire rack before filling.

Beat the heavy whipping cream with a mixer on medium until it begins to get frothy and thicken slightly. Add in the vanilla and then the brown sugar, a little at a time, until fully incorporated. Increase speed and continue whipping until cream stiffens and soft peaks form. Scrape out into a separate bowl and set aside. In the same mixing bowl, add the peanut butter and cream cheese; beat on medium until smooth and well blended.

Add 1/2 of the whipped cream into the peanut butter mixture and fold in by hand until blended. Add the remaining whipped cream; fold in. Transfer to the prepared and cooled chocolate crust and swirl or smooth out top. Sprinkle with nuts, cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for several hours or overnight.

Remove from refrigerator, allow to sit for about 5 to 10 minutes before slicing. Drizzle each serving with the chocolate syrup before serving, or simply drizzle all over the top of the whole pie before slicing, if preferred.

Cook's Note: Oreos work well with this as do plain chocolate wafers, or to shortcut this, purchase a pre-made, commercial chocolate cookie crust.


Requires Adobe Reader - download it free!
©Deep South Dish
Are you on Facebook? If you haven't already, come and join the party! We have a lot of fun & there's always room for one more at the table.
Check These Recipes Out Too Y'all!

Old Fashioned Apple Pie
Old Fashioned Buttermilk Chess Pie
Classic Southern Pecan Pie

Posted by on August 28, 2010
Images and Full Post Content including Recipe ©Deep South Dish. Sharing links is welcomed and encouraged, but please do not repost or republish elsewhere such as other blogs, websites, or forums without explicit prior permission. All rights reserved.

Material Disclosure: Unless otherwise noted, you should assume that post links to the providers of goods and services mentioned, establish an affiliate relationship and/or other material connection and that I may be compensated when you purchase from a provider. You are never under any obligation to purchase anything when using my recipes and you should always perform due diligence before buying goods or services from anyone via the Internet or offline.

Bookmark and Share


  1. Oh, yum yum yum!!! I can always go for a chocolate crust filled with peanut butter goodness!!

    Although, when I think of 'peanut butter pie' I think of the custard/meringue one you mentioned and my mom always made. I've tweaked that one over the years, though, to make it faster for me, by using instant french vanilla pudding and topping with cool whip.

    Thanks for this recipe! Those Sables sound fab, too!

  2. Oh that is absolutely decadent. Peanut butter pie is a dessert I can't resist!

  3. Oh good googly moogly that sounds so wonderful. I don't like chocolate so I am just going to use graham cracker. Yum.

  4. This sounds like a keeper. YUM!

  5. I'm not a huge dessert guy but I'd be all over a piece of this pie, Mary!

  6. Mary! This would just go perfect
    with a hot cup of fresh coffee..and 1 fork 2 for plates needed..:0 Going to give this a does this ever look scrumptious..may I be one of your test tasters? :)

  7. I've tried to comment on this a couple of times, but computer is being non-compliant. Hopefully this is one will be the charm and I can say ohmygoshyum! I've made Emeril's version and it was delish.

  8. Book marked!

    There's nothing better than the combination of peanut butter & chocolate if you ask me! :)

    Thanks for another great recipe Mary!

  9. wow, yeah. I think I need that right now. . .

  10. You can't go wrong with peanut butter and eating a slice of this pie is much more civilized than eating a spoonful out of the jar.

  11. This would take peanut butter lovers to heaven. My husband would be right there with them!

  12. Oh my that looks so good! I loved peanut butter, I wish my toddler wasn't allergic!

  13. i make peanut butter on the holidays, never tried one with brown sugar. ill have to try it, sounds like it taste wonderful.

  14. have made this a few times - excellent! thank you

  15. You're welcome & thanks so much for taking the time to come by and comment about it. I appreciate that!


Thanks for taking the time to comment - I love hearing from readers and I read every single comment and try to respond to them right here on the site, so stop back by!

From time to time, anonymous restrictions and/or comment moderation may be activated due to comment spam. I also reserve the right to edit, delete or otherwise exercise total editorial discretion over any comments left on this blog. If your comment serves only to be snarky, mean-spirited or argumentative, it will be deleted. Please mind your manners.

Related Posts with Thumbnails