![]() |
| One of the most popular recipes on the site, this casserole gives a feeling of good ole chicken & dumplings, but in an easy casserole form. |
Chicken and Dumpling Bake Casserole
This Chicken and Dumpling Bake may not be real photogenic but it is simply delicious and another one of those foods that proves you can't judge a book by its cover. While the name may be the same, this version is of course, a casserole, and not technically exactly like good ole old fashioned chicken and dumplings. To me, however, it provides a consistency and flavor similar to the more labor-intensive homemade version, but in a super-easy form, especially if you are using leftover chicken or a rotissiere chicken from the grocery store. If you are cooking fresh chicken, especially if you are using boneless, skinless chicken you want to just slightly under cook it when you poach it, since it will essentially continue cooking in the oven.You'll note that there is (purposely) no salt included in this recipe. That's because between the cream of chicken soup and the chicken stock, there is really plenty of salt to flavor the dish, so don't add any to the recipe till you taste it. I don't find it to need any other seasonings either, but certainly add any of your favorites that you like either in the casserole or in the broth if you're adding in vegetables. I generally prefer mixed chicken in most chicken casseroles, but I'm still working through an abundance of chicken breasts from my freezer, so that's what I used for this post. Use whatever you have. This casserole is a great family pleaser - hope you give it a try.
Here's how to make it. Enjoy!
First things first, if you're using raw chicken, you'll need to bring 2 cups of chicken stock to a boil. If you're using a rotisserie chicken or precooked chicken you'll skip these first few steps of course.
Add the chicken breasts (or whatever pieces you are using) to the stock, bring back up to a boil, cover, reduce to simmer and cook for about 15 minutes.
Remove chicken and set aside to cool. Reserve the stock - you'll need it in a second.
Melt 1/2 a stick of butter and pour into a 9 x 13 inch baking pan.
When the chicken has cooled down, shred it. I usually use two forks to do this. If you are substituting a rotisserie chicken, please keep in mind they are generally salty and consider that in any other source of sodium that you are using (the soup, broth & flour).
Spread the chicken on top of the butter in the baking pan.
Combine 1 cup of milk with 1 cup of self-rising flour. You can also substitute regular all purpose flour - simply add in 1-1/4 teaspoons of baking powder plus 1/8 teaspoon of salt and whisk that together before mixing with the milk.
And whisk that together.
Pour the flour mixture very slowly over the chicken so not to move the chicken around.
Don't stir!
Now strain the chicken stock that you used to cook the chicken in.
Add the cream of chicken soup to that. This, as all casseroles, works best with the original cream soup concentrates, rather than the green label version such as Healthy Request lower fat, which tend to make it soupy.
And whisk it until it's well blended.
Pour that very slowly and carefully over the flour and milk mixture.
Again, do not stir!
Bake at 400 degrees F about 35 to 45 minutes or until top begins to brown. Remember all ovens vary in hot spots and temperature fluctuations so your time may be different.

Allow the casserole to rest and settle before serving.

If you think this sounds yummy, I'd sure ♥ it if you'd click to pin it, tweet it, stumble it, or share it on Facebook to help spread the word - thanks!
Share Tweet
Recipe: Chicken and Dumpling Bake
©From the Kitchen of Deep South Dish
Prep time: 15 min |Cook time: 45 min | Yield: About 8 to 12 servings
Ingredients:
Instructions:
- 3-4 cups of cooked chicken
- 1/4 cup (1/2 stick) of unsalted butter
- 1 cup of self-rising flour
- 1 cup of milk
- 2 cups of chicken stock/broth (low sodium is best)
- 1 can of Campbell's original condensed cream of chicken soup
If you are using fresh, raw chicken, please see cook's notes at the bottom of the recipe. Preheat the oven to 400 degrees F. Melt 1/2 stick of butter and pour into the bottom of a 9 x 13 inch baking pan. Shred the chicken and spread it on top of the butter. In a separate bowl, whisk together the milk and the flour and slowly pour that over the chicken taking care not to disturb the chicken too much. Do not stir. Whisk together the chicken broth and the cream of chicken soup. Slowly pour that over the flour and milk mixture. Do not stir.
Bake uncovered at 400 degrees F for 35 to 45 minutes, or until top is light golden brown. All ovens vary. Let casserole rest before serving.
Cooks Notes: Use rotisserie chicken, leftover precooked chicken, canned chicken or 3 to 5 pieces of raw chicken - chicken breasts, mixed chicken parts. When using other sources of chicken other than freshly cooked, such as canned or a pre-cooked rotisserie chicken, they are already fairly salty, so keep that in mind with the other products you are using containing sodium (broth, soup). Poach raw chicken in the chicken broth or stock in a medium sized saucepan. Cook on a low simmer for about 15 to 20 minutes or until chicken is mostly done. It will finish cooking in the oven. Remove the chicken and set aside to cool but reserve the stock. To substitute all purpose flour, use 1 cup of flour and add 1-1/4 teaspoon of baking powder plus 1/8 teaspoons of salt. Leftovers reheat nicely, but casserole does not freeze well.
Chicken Pot Pie Casserole: Several readers like to make this an all-in-one meal by adding drained canned mixed veggies, or cooked/steamed frozen or fresh veggies. Cook 2 sliced carrots, 2 sliced celery stalks, a diced potato and a chopped onion, in about 3 cups of chicken broth. Can season the water with bay leaf, herbs or other non-salt seasonings. When the veggies are tender, drain but reserve the broth. Put the veggies on top of the shredded chicken and add about 1-1/2 cups of frozen peas. Finished as above, using the reserved broth from the veggies.
Source: http://deepsouthdish.com
Requires Adobe Reader - download it free! ©Deep South Dish
☛ Are you on Facebook? If you haven't already, come and join the party! We have a lot of fun & there's always room for one more at the table.
Chicken and Gravy
Chicken and Drop Dumplings
Homemade Chicken Noodle Soup
Images and Full Post Content including Recipe ©Deep South Dish. Pinning and sharing links is welcomed and encouraged, but please do not repost or republish elsewhere such as other blogs, websites, or forums without explicit prior permission. All rights reserved.
Material Disclosure: Unless otherwise noted, you should assume that post links to the providers of goods and services mentioned, establish an affiliate relationship and/or other material connection and that I may be compensated when you purchase from a provider. You are never under any obligation to purchase anything when using my recipes and you should always perform due diligence before buying goods or services from anyone via the Internet or offline.
.



















































I've never had chicken and dumplings like this before!!!! YUM!!!!
ReplyDeleteWell.... it's not exactly chicken and dumplings because there aren't actual cut dumplings involved, but it gives you that "feeling" because of the texture with all how the flour bakes into the mixture. (Does that makes sense LOL???)
ReplyDeleteMmmmmm, makes sense to me! Love chicken and dumplin's, so I am sure I will like this. Do you roll and cut dumplin's? I drop the batter. I've never had the rolled and cut dumplin's.
ReplyDeleteThis looks amazing! I'm a big fan of chicken and dumplings. Ultimate comfort food! I'll have to try this one soon.
ReplyDeleteI'm loving your blog, thanks for stopping by mine. I love Southern cooking...and Southern women for that matter. We lived South of Atlanta for 18 months until we moved back to the Midwest over the summer. Those women were amazing. Talk about Southern hospitality. Not only did they make me feel right at home and welcome, they brought me delicious chicken and dumplings. And now we've come full circle...better sign off.
Just wanted to say: I'm a fan!
I have to say this is a beautiful blog site! I actually was going to make Chicken and Dumplings this week. Now I am going to make this instead. Glad I found you.
ReplyDeleteHi Krista and Nana! Thanks so much for stopping by and takin' the time to stop and write. Hope to see more of y'all around again too!!
ReplyDeleteOMG! This blog looks good enough to eat.
ReplyDeleteI'm so glad I found you via The Secret Is In The Sauce. I am definitely linking to you.
Oh my goodness what a great compliment! Thanks so much!!
ReplyDeleteWow, I haven't have chicken and dumplin for many years, gonna try this recipe very soon. Thanks, and keep those good dishes comin.
ReplyDeleteThis recipe , I have to say was soooo easy and tasty ..I make Chicken and Dumplings alot ..and lastnight I did not want to do it ..so instead I followed your recipe...and it was wonderful ...the creaminess ooo wow is all I can say ...I paired it up with Fresh corn and Homemade Biscuits .... The kids wanted more ..but I ran out. Smiles Thanks for this recipe ...it will continue to warm our families stomachs for years to come!! huggs, Kellie
ReplyDeleteI tried this recipe for the first time last night.My husband loves chicken and dumplings.He loved this dish.He went back for thirds haha!
ReplyDeleteSomehow I missed this when I was looking through your archives, but a blog friend pointed it out and I'm glad she did! It's wonderful, and wonderfully easy!
ReplyDeleteI make rolled and cut dumplings, drop dumplings and also steamed dumplings where I make a seasoned biscuit dough dropped onto a perforated pizza pan that sits over a wide pot of boiling water. (Cover with a domed lid and steam until done.) The creamy chicken gravy is spooned over them just like sausage gravy on biscuits. I learned to make them when I worked for a caterer and they are a huge pain to make but oh so worth it.
They make me appreciate your easy, tasty recipe all the more. :)
This was so YUMMY!My family of 7 ate it up. I'm expecting again and I've been craving this like crazy. Thanks so much for all the great recipes :)
ReplyDeleteThanks so much everybody! So glad you all enjoyed it - it's a favorite around our house for sure.
ReplyDeleteI'm making this for dinner tonight. Again!
ReplyDeleteI made this recipe yesterday and it was wonderful! It looked exactly like the pictures you posted, and my husband and I loved it. Thanks for this recipe!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much y'all!!
ReplyDeleteDoes anyone know if this dish will freeze? I know I roll my dumplings out and freeze them in advance so I don't have as much work to do Thanksgiving morning. Just wondering, then I can be a whole step closer.
ReplyDeleteLeft overs are great but NO it does not freeze well
DeleteDoes anyone know if this dish will freeze well so I can make it ahead of time and just pop it in the oven Thanksgiving morning?
ReplyDeleteno it does not
DeleteHonestly I don't know about freezing this, but I don't think I would. You could certainly prepare the chicken ahead, but the batter is not something that I think you could pour on and expect the same results. That said, if you'd got cooked chicken, this comes together very quick. Enjoy!
ReplyDeleteI have actually tried freezing this dish before it has been cooked and I did not get very good results...the consistency is not as good as when you first bake it ... I have also froze it after baking ... its just not the same as baking it the very fist time. I agree with mary ..this is a quick dish to make. just buy a rotiseri chicken to make it quicker. hope that helps.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much Kellie - I had a feeling this might not translate well to the freezer - I appreciate you popping back by the share your experience! Thanks so much!!
ReplyDeleteThanks, guess I'll not make it and freeze for Thanksgiving. I'll make the real thing that morning.
ReplyDeleteI just put this in the oven, I think we are gonna be VERY happy!! The flavors are all my favorites. I did add some dried parsley and black pepper over the chicken. (just cause I like pepper in my dumplings). Thanks for a great recipe.
ReplyDeleteSounds like a great add in to me! Hope you enjoy it.
ReplyDeleteMade this for dinner with veggies and creamed corn biscuits. Delish!
ReplyDeleteLola, now that's one fine supper!! Glad you enjoyed it - it's a site favorite for sure.
ReplyDeleteI made this yesterday, very tasty and quick stand in for chicken and dumplings. I sprinkled a little black pepper on the top and added a handful of frozen peas, just because I needed to use them :-) I bought an extra rotisserie chicken from Costco with the intent to use some of it for this recipe. I didn't add any salt as you mentioned, and it was perfect. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteSpyce, so glad you enjoyed it! Thanks so much for taking the time to come back and comment!
ReplyDeleteI am making this for dinner tonight, because it looks so good, and the reviews where great for the recipe. I used a Rotisserie Chicken from Costco and added pepper. It smells good.
ReplyDeleteHope you like it!
ReplyDeleteUgg just when I'm on a diet but I've saved it for future references. I can make it gluten free too! I'll let you know how it taste! :)
ReplyDeleteMade this tonight and it was a big hit! My husband went back for seconds...and thirds! And my two year old loved it too! I hid some cooked carrots in hers. ;-). I am becoming a fan of your site. I made the king cake last week...yummy!
ReplyDeleteHi Joanna! Glad it was a hit!! It is a site favorite, probably because it is both easy and tasty!! So glad you're enjoying the recipes and thanks so much for reading and for taking the time to come back and comment - I really appreciate that!!
ReplyDeleteI think I need you to move into my house- my kids absolutely adore all your recipes and this was no exception! I threw in frozen corn and peas and some diced carrots which were hidden nicely among the chicken for my veggie hater 6 year old- thanks Mary, this is definitely a keeper, and I can use the stock to make your delicious chicken and dumpling soup.
ReplyDeleteJane xx
You're so welcome Jane! Thanks for taking the time to come back and comment!!
ReplyDeleteVery good and very easy. I won't be making it the other way ever again!
ReplyDeleteGlad you enjoyed it Karen! Thanks for taking the time to come back and comment.
ReplyDeleteOh wow...I made this last night and it was a winner! Its all I can talk about today:) my hubby said its definitely a keeper. Thanks for sharing your wonderful recipes. Love them!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much! It's a site favorite - so glad y'all enjoyed it!!
ReplyDeleteGreat for when your short on time. I made this 2 weeks ago, very easy. But next time I'll double the recipe.
ReplyDeleteI'll probably add veg all and call it pot pie! Sounds so easy, yea!
ReplyDeleteUpdate: I made this again with a homemade cream of chicken soup (flour, butter, milk, broth) and it was even BETTER!! :-)
ReplyDeleteBaking this now.. cant wait to taste it.. I did substitute.. I used bisquick instead of flour.. I have make dumplings before with bisquick so.. I used six thighs instead of breasts.. I will let you know how it turned out thanks for sharing this easy recipe. Sandy
ReplyDeleteI love,love, love your site !!!! Good ole southern cooking like my Mom & Grandmother made. Everything sounds so delicious, I don't know what to try next.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much and welcome!!
ReplyDeleteI can't wait to make this! I've never made chicken & dumplings - this looks easy enough for me to finally give it a try!! Thanks Mary!
ReplyDeleteIt's a casserole representation of it but not quite the same, though it is a site favorite Steph! I do have a regular chicken and dumplings recipe on here too though if you ever want it. This isn't the one I was talking about on Twitter the other day - I haven't posted the other casserole yet, probably next week or whenever I can get it typed up. Things are crazy right now. It only took me months to make it LOL! :)
ReplyDeleteDoes anyone know if you can use salted butter thats all i have on hand
DeleteSure! Just keep in mind any added salt you have elsewhere. There is some in the self rising flour & you'll have sodium in your broth or bouillon if you make your own broth, and sodium in the soup, though you can use lower sodium products for both of those. That's why I mostly use unsalted butter so I can have more control over the other sodium.
DeletePosted you to my face book page for all my friends and family to enjoy.Yours is hands down the best recipe site ever!
ReplyDeleteThank you and thanks for sharing my site with your friends and family too! I appreciate that!!
ReplyDeleteI am making this tonight! I absolutely love this site!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much Julie - hope you enjoy the casserole!!
ReplyDeletecan this be made the night before?
ReplyDeleteHi Sandy! Honestly I don't know. Haven't tried to fully assemble this ahead because it comes together so fast, so long as you have your chicken cooked already. You could certainly do that ahead with no problem - just remember to reserve the broth & don't dump it! From there it's just a simple whisk of flour and milk to pour over the top of the chicken, and mixing the chicken broth and cream soup to pour that on top of the flour/milk mixture. If you decide to try it, let me know!
ReplyDeleteMary, I hope you don't mind me adding to your last comment. I have made this dish many times and once in a while (not often!) we have leftovers. In my opinion, leftovers would be the same as making this the night before and re-heating it. We love all kinds of leftovers here, and the leftovers of this dish are good, but I have to say that this is one dish that is better fresh out of the oven.
ReplyDeleteOf course! Thanks for the input Annie!
ReplyDeleteFound this through Pinterest and made it last night for dinner. It was delicious! All 3 of my kids loved it...and you know what a triumph that is! LOL! There were no leftovers. Thanks for sharing this recipe!
ReplyDeleteYes I do Lauri - glad they enjoyed it! Thanks so much for stopping back by to let me know that you tried it too. I appreciate that!
ReplyDeleteMade this last night & it was sooooo yummy! My boyfriend even called me this morning & asked for me to bring him leftovers for lunch.
ReplyDeleteThanks Ashli! Glad he enjoyed it.
ReplyDeleteThis was SO SO GOOD!!! Perfect comfort food and so very easy to make = ]
ReplyDeleteI will make this again and again...
Thank you Quela!
ReplyDeletemaking this tonight can't wait to taste it.....thanks for this simple but I am sure will be delicious recipe.
ReplyDeleteIt turned out soupy, anyone know why this might have happened??? Thanks
ReplyDeleteHi Camden Crew! Shouldn't be soupy. Can you tell me if you made any adjustments to the recipe ingredients?
ReplyDeleteIt was a little soupy at first, I think that I should have let it sit for about 5 mins after I took it out of the oven. I didn't do anything different and even went over it several times to make sure I didn't miss anything....It turned out pretty good after I let it sit, will make again and add a little salt and pepper because I used the broth from the split chicken breast that I boiled. Made some biscuits to go with....thank for the recipe
ReplyDeleteOh good - glad to hear it!!
ReplyDeletemade this for dinner tonight after i found it on your site! it had great flavor and was very creamy! I halved the recipe, as i was making it for only 2 people, but it turned out great! i must admit i accidentally over-baked it when i got busy and forgot to set the oven timer (so my chicken was a bit chewy) but the flavor was still great! thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteGlad you enjoyed it Becki!
ReplyDeleteI tried this last night and all I can tell you is that the ENTIRE RECIPE got eaten up by myself, my husband and my teenage son. I had planned on having leftovers!
ReplyDeleteI'm so glad that you enjoyed it! Thanks so much for taking the time to come back and leave a comment to let me know.
ReplyDeleteThis is as good as my Granny's made from scratch...Friends loved it too. Thank for a wonderful dish.......
ReplyDeleteFound this recipe on Pinterest and decided to make it tonight. My family loved it! I can't believe how easy it was to make!
ReplyDeleteOh Val I love this dish but I'm sure your Granny's real C&D is much better!! Glad you enjoyed it - it's certainly a site favorite.
ReplyDeleteI know Michelle, right? I made it tonight myself - we love it!!
Yet another comment on this recipe and yet another variation. I used the leftover pork from your Smothered Pork and Rice recipe in place of the chicken, and I used the pork gravy from the same recipe in place of the chicken broth/cream soup mixture in this recipe. Delicious!
ReplyDeleteLOL Annie, but that's okay - I love all the variations you come up with. That sounds great!!
ReplyDeleteThis recipe is a life-saver...well, maybe that's a little dramatic. Anyway, my husband LOVES chicken and dumplins. I've been trying to master them since we've been married. Sometimes I make them and they're great, sometimes they're horrible. This recipe is no-fail though. I found this on Pinterest and decided to try it instead of the old-fashioned version. He loved it! It is officially in my recipe book. Thanks so much. I won't have to labor in the kitchen and cross my fingers my dumplins turn out!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome Cherith & I'm so glad that your husband enjoyed this!!
ReplyDeleteMary,
ReplyDeleteMy husband & I loved this recipe. So easy and he said immediately, this is a keeper. He can't wait until tomorrow night for leftovers. I can always depend on your recipes being great. Keep on doing what you do best!
Thanks Brenda! It's certainly a favorite around here & I'm so glad y'all enjoyed it. Thanks so much for taking the time to come back and let me know!!
DeleteFABULOUS! I cooked a whole chicken the day before shredded and put in fridge. All I had to do was melt butter in pan, throw chicken on top, mix milk and flour and chicken broth and soup... this was amazing and so easy! My husband loved it! We ate it served on mashed potatoes. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome! It's a man and kid pleaser for sure - thanks so much for taking the time for coming back to let me know that y'all enjoyed it. I do appreciate that!
ReplyDeletei found this recipe via Pinterest and decided to try it for dinner tonight. to be honest, i didn't have very high expectations for it, but i must say, i was very pleasantly surprised. my husband and i both really liked it. i'll definitely be making it again in the future. thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteGod bless! :)
So glad that it exceeded your expectations Emily! It's really so simple but very delicious - I'm glad y'all enjoyed it!
Deletemade it AGAIN for dinner last night! lol! we liked it just as much, if not more, the second time around! :)
DeleteIsn't it ridiculous?!!! Love things that are so easy but yet so tasty. This recipe has gone kinda viral for that very reason. Have a wonderful Friday & weekend Emily!
DeleteI overcooked it and kinda burnt the bottom to a golden-y brown crisp AND I STILL ATE 3 HELPINGS (in the form of 2 giant bowls, so technically it was only 2 helpings...yeah, we'll go with that story). Oh my GOSH was it good! I added peas and carrots and garlic/onion powder and will not be sharing ONE BIT of the entire casserole with anyone! I feel like I need to give you a huge, warm hug and bake you a buttermilk peach pie as a thank you for this recipe--because as we all know, thank you's are best said with baked goods. ;)
ReplyDeleteLOL, I understand the whole burning thing - I am notorious for getting distracted and doing that myself!! So glad you enjoyed it Kayli & thank you!
DeleteI just made this for dinner tonight......the hubby & I LOVED it!!!! Another awesome recipe from Deep South Dish:)))). I did add some extras: fresh thyme, fresh parsley & Slap Ya Mama (of course) - will DEFINITELY make this again!!!
ReplyDeleteYou know every time I think about adding in extra seasonings on this one I back out & leave it alone, though I don't realy know why! Glad y'all enjoyed it Tricia!
Deletemade this and it was so yummy. Going to share it on my family blog and give you and your blog full credit with a link. look forward to makin it again!thanks for sharing
ReplyDeleteGlad that you enjoyed it Jaime!
DeleteI was wondering if this could be made into a freezer meal, if so what changes (if any) should be made? Thanks in advance!
ReplyDeleteHi Sally! No, I wouldn't recommend freezing this dish based on Kellie's experience a few comments up. It doesn't take long to put together though!
DeleteMade this for dinner last night, and everyone loved it! My only (minor) complaint - I would have liked more dumplings. I didn't measure my shredded chicken - just used 4 chicken breasts. They were from Costco, so maybe bigger than average? Anyway, it was excellent. I've loved all of your recipes that we've tried. Thanks!!
ReplyDeleteCould be - some of those breasts are mighty plump! Anyway, you want somewhere between 3 to 4 cups shredded chicken overall. I'm glad the family enjoyed the dish & thanks for stopping back by to let me know!
DeleteI guess if I would've read the recipe in the yellow area, I would've gotten my answer. I just read the steps...
ReplyDeleteLooks delish! I'm making it for lunch for my kiddos today!
Laurel :)
No problem Laurel!! Maybe I need to clarify in the tutorial a bit better - it's hard being your own editor at times. I don't think that's bound to change at any point so thanks for letting me know. Anyway, while it's not like the real deal chicken & dumplings of course, it's sure a nice quick casserole that gives a similar flavor and it's definitely a site favorite. I hope that everybody enjoyed the recipe!
DeleteThis is in the oven right now... Can't wait to try it! I tink next time I will add a few potatoes and carrots.
ReplyDeleteIt's delicious all on its own, but also very easy to add to - hope that you enjoyed it!
DeleteThis is a great substitute for real dumplings!! ;D Thank you, excellent meal!
ReplyDeleteThanks Lynea - glad y'all enjoyed it & I truly appreciate you stopping back over to let me know. Thanks so much!!
DeleteDEAR MARY ,WE JUST ATE THE DUMPLING CASSEROLE!!!! WOW ,JUST GREAT .THANK YOU !!! WILL BE MADE AGAIN ,FOR SURE !!!!!GENNY AUG.19TH 2012
ReplyDeleteThanks so much Genevieve! It's one of my favorite casseroles too!! Thank you for taking the time to come back and comment - I really appreciate hearing from readers when they try recipes. Thanks again!!
DeleteDear Mary
ReplyDeleteThe dumpling casserole was a success. Will definetly be on my menu again.
Thanks Genny
I have some precooked chicken already, which means I don't need to cook the chicken in the chicken stock. So, do I still need to mix 2 full cups of chicken stock with the cream of chicken soup at the end of the recipe? If I would have to cook chicken in in the chicken stock, then some of that 2 cups of stock would typically boil down a little. I don't want to have a watery casserole from mixing too much stock with the soup. Thanks..and can't wait to try the recipe :)
ReplyDeleteYes, you do need the 2 cups of broth regardless of whether it's from cooking the chicken or from bouillon or canned/boxed broth. If you're cooking raw chicken, I just didn't want you to throw that out. Hope that helps!
DeleteWas delicious but way too salty. Next Tim's I won't add salt to the flour mixture. Very yummy and easy dish though!
ReplyDeleteHi! I'm so glad you enjoyed it. Thinking about it being overly salty - if you're using a commercial chicken broth that would definitely bring in extra salt. If you use bouillon to make the broth, that is highly salty. Try it next time using unsalted butter, low sodium chicken broth, and no added salt if you're doing a homemade substitute for the self rising flour. That will leave the only major salt source the cream soup & you can actually also use the lower sodium soup, but remember, you do want some salt for the flavor so don't eliminate all the sources. I think that will help - let me know!
DeleteI made a gluten free version of this tonight. It had the exact taste of chicken and dumplings, but not the texture. It was more of a thick dumpling sauce. I'm not sure if this was caused by the gluten-free flour. Sometimes things don't work out as they do with traditional flours. Regardless I'll try it again because we enjoyed the taste. Thanks for the recipe!
ReplyDeleteVery likely the gluten free flour because the flour does form a fluffy layer, reminiscent of a dumplings and not a sauce.. but I'm glad you enjoyed it Tracy! It is s tasty little casserole.
DeleteI've been intending to try this recipe for some time and finally got around to it a few nights ago -it was a big hit. It's a perfect dish to make when you want comfort food but you don't have a lot of time to spare. I'm going put this in my "rotation" of dinner recipes. I enjoy your website so much, I appreciate all the time and effort you must spend on it.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for that sweet comment! I probably spend as much time working on this website as I have on any other job I've ever held as a workaholic, so it really makes me happy to see that it shows. Thank you.
DeleteI love this casserole too - while it's not like homemade chicken and dumplings, it's sure a great way to get the flavor in a casserole form!
made this tonight with the hopes of having dumplings,.. sad to say, It didnt happen. I only added some seasonings to the broth while cooking the chicken. and didnt change a thing. It still tasted good, but we sure missed having a nice thick dumpling to sink our teeth into. I don't know what I did wrong.
ReplyDeleteOh darn Sharon, I'm sure you didn't do anything wrong & I hate that you were disappointed! This is not a "chicken and dumpling" recipe. It's a casserole - so while it's reminiscent of chicken and dumplings flavor but in a casserole form, it's not like the real deal chicken with dumplings. No casserole will ever be able to match up to that.
DeleteI do have a couple of chicken and dumpling recipes here that would probably be more to your liking if that is what you were expecting, but they do take a bit more work - although one is a quicker shortcut version from stewing down a whole chicken. This is just an easy casserole that have the flavor but can't match the original!!
Thanks for your reply. it just reminded me of creamed chicken. LOL. I will look up your other chicken and dumpling recipes.
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome! You can't beat homemade chicken and dumplings - probably my #1 comfort food. Most southerners like the rolled, flat dumplings but I've always preferred drop dumplings - nice & fluffy. That's how my Mama made them. It sounds like that's what you're looking for too.
DeleteFor this casserole, the bottom layer should be a little bit like a stewed chicken would be when it's cooked, but the flour and milk layer that you pour over the chicken should puff up when it bakes and push through the cream soup and broth topping in sections, to form bubbly puffs in the casserole that's reminiscent of a dumpling. The top layer isn't just a crust, it should have some puffy lumps in it.
Self rising flour works best for this casserole so it rises and puffs up well. If you substitute regular all purpose flour & add in the baking powder yourself, make sure you are using fresh baking powder too or else it won't rise either - and always shake your baking powder container anytime you use it. Plain all purpose flour alone will not work.
Anyway, these characteristics are why I called it chicken and dumpling casserole! Did yours not look at all like the picture at the top?
I just made this recipe and the same thing happened to me. It's pretty soupy. I'm guessing it's because my baking powder is not fresh. I wish I would have seen this comment before I made it. Oh well!
DeleteBe sure to let it cook long enough - all ovens vary - and also that you let it rest. Also, don't know if you made any adjustments, but if you use the Healthy Request lower fat soups, those tend to be soupy in a casserole too.
DeleteHaving lived in GA for 3 years, and now misssing some of the good Southern food, when I found your site, it was immediately bookmarked for later use. Made this last night, but added tabasco sauce and cheese for a cold-cure and it turned out fantastic. Only regret is that I didn't make more :P
ReplyDeleteMaking creamy chicken tortilla soup tonight, as per your recipe, and hoping it turns out just as nice :)
Thank you for the amazing recipes, me and my housemates love them :)
Thanks Katie! Hope you also enjoy the chicken tortilla soup & get to feeling better soon!
DeleteHaving lived in GA for 3 years, I miss some of the good Southern food, so when I found your site, it was immediately bookmarked for later use. Made this last night, adding cheese and Tabasco sauce (brilliant cold-cure) and it turned out fantastic. My only regret is that I didn't make more :P
ReplyDeleteMaking creamy chicken tortilla soup tonight, as per your recipe, and hopefully it'll turn out just as nice.
Thank you for the amazing recipes, me and my house mates love them, and I have a feeling I'll be using many more of them in the future :)
Thanks so much Katie - I hope that you enjoyed the soup also!
DeleteMade this last night. My husband gave me the crazy eye when he saw it in the pan. As you said, NOT the most beautiful dish but Lordy! SO yummy! My eight year old asked to eat leftovers for breakfast! Hehe
ReplyDeleteThanks for another keeper! I truly enjoy your site and your delicious recipes :)
Yeah, it's not the prettiest dish on the block, but it sure is good! Glad y'all enjoyed it & thanks for letting me know!
DeleteJust made this dish for the first time tonight. Really simple, fast and DELICIOUS. Served with green beans made a great dinner. Going to have it over fresh hot corn bread next time.
ReplyDeleteThanks Jim - glad you enjoyed it!
DeleteMade this last night for dinner and the family ate the whole thing! This dish will definitely be served regularly! Thanks Mary!
ReplyDeleteI'm so happy they enjoyed it Kat - thanks for letting me know!!
DeleteMy sisters and I made this a few weeks ago. We made the pot pie version. It was delicious! We all loved it, but it didn't look anything like your pic. We added carrots, celery, potatoes, onion and frozen peas, all cooked in the chicken broth and seasoned with a bay leaf. It was delicious! Thanks for sharing your recipes.
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome Kim & I'm so glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for stopping back by to let me know! As for the picture, I can assure you that the casserole pictured here in my post is indeed a picture that I took of this very casserole recipe. Except for the add-ins I didn't use, your casserole should look somewhat similar!
DeleteI have an adult day care center and while my chef was on vacation, I made this for my clients. It was a HUGE hit! I now have one in the oven for my family. Thank you for sharing this awesome recipe!
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome Lisa & I'm thrilled it was a hit!!
DeleteThis was beyond awesome and so easy to make. My husband loved it and already wants me to make it again so he will have some to take for his lunch this week. I have passed this on to my friends too!! Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteYou're so welcome! I'm glad that your husband enjoyed it - that's always a compliment to me to get the hubby approval! Thank you so much for taking the time to come back by and let me know you enjoyed it too Lori!
DeleteI have made this twice and it is easy and great!
ReplyDeleteThanks Sherry!
DeleteI have made this twice and it was easy and great.
ReplyDeleteOoof! I'm stuffed! It was delicious...It took more like 50 minutes in the oven and 10 minutes sitting to be the right consistency for me, but I may have expected more "dumplings" than I should have. I served with some smothered green beans and biscuits...bomb diggity awesomeness!
ReplyDeleteGlad you enjoyed it!
DeleteOooof...I'm stuffed! It was awesome. It took 50 minutes in the oven and another 10 sitting to be the right consistency for me, but I may have expected more "dumplings" than intended. I served it with smothered green beans and biscuits (I am a Southern girl after all). Delicousness!!!
ReplyDeleteOk so I used your dumplings on chilli....omgoodness what a hit!!!! We love drop and cut dumplings... Oh hell we just love dumplings!!! I seasoned the batter with polenta style fine cornmeal, parsely, garlic and a bit if fresh basil and dill... This batter held the herbs and took the meal so well....it puffed so beautifully.. you basically saved my bacon for dinner tonight. Thank you!!!! your blog is a treasure!!!
ReplyDeleteI think you are onto something here!! Thanks so much & glad that you were inspired!
DeleteWould this keep for a couple of hours all mixed and not baked? Trying to make some easy dinners for my grandaughter when she gives birth to her second baby. I would like for her to just be able to pop it in the oven. Thanks for all your recipes. Love them!
ReplyDeleteNot really sure Rosemary - but it does reheat nicely in case you want to bake it a little short, let cool & wrap. Thanks so much - I'm glad you're enjoying the recipes & congratulations on the new grandbaby!!
ReplyDeleteI'm going to give this a try later this week - it looks great, and REALLY reminds me of my grandmother's chicken pie recipe (the main difference being that hers was the chicken, cream of celery soup, broth, and butter all mixed up and then a cup of Bisquick/cup of milk mixed together and poured on top for the crust). I think I've already got all the ingredients!
ReplyDeleteI just found your site so I think I'll be getting several recipes from here - I already can't wait to try the Sour Cherry Lemonade too!
It's really very much like a chicken pie - layering the ingredients rather than mixing them together is what makes it lumpy and dumpling like! Please let me know what you think!
DeleteI made it yesterday (couldn't wait til later in the week!). It turned out pretty good - I was a little pushed for time so I used a rotisserie chicken and Bisquick instead of self-rising flour. I liked it, though I think that since it looked kind of like my grandma's chicken pie my mouth was expecting it to taste a little more like it - I did really like it but the cream of chicken soup was a little bit bland in comparison to cream of celery. So I think next time I make it I'll use fresh chicken that I've boiled myself and probably some cream of celery soup instead. But I really did like it! Thanks again for the recipe!
DeleteAnd sorry for the duplicate post below - not sure how that happened!
I'm going to give this a try later this week - it looks great, and REALLY reminds me of my grandmother's chicken pie recipe (the main difference being that hers was the chicken, cream of celery soup, broth, and butter all mixed up and then a cup of Bisquick/cup of milk mixed together and poured on top for the crust). I think I've already got all the ingredients!
ReplyDeleteI just found your site so I think I'll be getting several recipes from here - I already can't wait to try the Sour Cherry Lemonade too!
I made this earlier this morning for dinner tonight. My kids kept trying to figure out what it was. I did taste it before I went to work and I must say......It was Wonderful!! :) My husband and son have been asking me for weeks to make chicken and dumplings and this will definetly hit the spot. Thanks so much!!!
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome Andrea & thanks so much for coming back by with feedback! It's not quite the same as good ole old fashioned chicken and dumplings of course, but it's a nice easy casserole for in between.
Delete